Tenders were posted on a public procurement website to be held in the format of an electronic tender for awarding a contract on the conservation of archaeological heritage sites.
In evaluating the bids, the tender commission took into account the following two criteria:
- a price criterion: whoever who offers the best, i.e., the lowest, price, would get the most points; and
- a non-price criterion: whoever is able to submit more employment contracts concluded with specialists in the field of archeology.
The tender commission admitted two bidders to the tender, one of whom was declared the winner.
The second bidder had doubts about the reliability of the information stated in the winner's bid and decided to appeal the results of the tender in a commercial court.
Tenders were posted on a public procurement website to be held in the format of an electronic tender for awarding a contract on the conservation of archaeological heritage sites. The tender commission admitted two bidders to the tender, one of whom was declared the winner.
The second bidder had doubts about the reliability of the information stated in the winner's bid and decided to appeal the results of the tender in a commercial court. The task of the lawyers was: to prove that the winner of the tender provided falsified employment agreements and challenge the decision of the state commission.
The lawyers did the following:
1. Requested information about the relevant employees from the tax authorities and about insured persons from the pension fund. The efforts included contacting every existing employee of the winner and obtaining written information about the actual employment.
2. Sent requests for information on handwriting examination.
3. Found out that at least 12 out of 16 employment agreements turned out to be unauthentic.
After the claimant filed an application on the fabrication of evidence, the winner of the tender was forced to negotiate an amicable settlement of the dispute. Our lawyers’ efforts resulted in achieving an out-of-court settlement of the dispute. The client was satisfied with the result and the proceedings were terminated.