Protection Against Fake Creditors in Bankruptcy Cases

Unscrupulous creditors with claims that were not based on real business relationships sought to have their fake claims included into the creditors’ list.

By representing our client, a legitimate creditor, we have succeeded in refusing the inclusion of fake claims into the creditors’ list.

Case was handled by

In the course of bankruptcy proceedings, unscrupulous creditors filed claims against the debtor in the amount of about RUB 45 mln under loan agreements and special machinery supply and lease contracts.  They sought to have their artificial claims included in the register of creditors' claims. The task of the lawyers was: to ensure that the fictitious claims were not included in the register.          

The lawyers drew the court's attention to a number of critical factors and convinced the jury that the claims asserted by the unscrupulous creditors were based on the alleged transactions made for the sake of appearance.

The court took into account signs of the absence of real economic relations between the unscrupulous creditors and the debtor, such as:

1. Failure to prove the actual delivery of the goods (real and not as appeared from documents only);

2. The fact that the creditors did not own any special equipment that was allegedly leased out to the debtor;

3. The fact that the creditors did not have a sufficient number of employees to carry out business operations;

4. Misrepresentations and defects identified in the primary documents and contracts which were confirmed in court;

5. Abnormal inactivity of the creditors in repayment of the debt over a long period of time given the considerable amount of such debt for the creditors (relative to their annual income). Eventually, the court refused to include RUB 45 mln of artificial claims in the register.

Related materials

We are here to help, please fill out the form below: