The parent company of a business group took three loans from a bank. Those loans were secured by guarantees issued by all of the companies in the group and by two partners. Furthermore, there was a collateral in the form of business properties owned by those two partners.
The guarantors repaid the loan for the principal debtor and the creditor's rights passed to them. This included the pledgee's rights. However, one of the partners who issued one of the guarantees elected to foreclose on the property pledged as a collateral.
Such state of affairs could entail the forced sale of the property, and, accordingly, its loss by the owner.
D2 Summary of matter and your department's role – Please say why this matter was important. Also, tell us exactly what role your department played.
The parent company of a business group took three loans from a bank. Those loans were secured by guarantees issued by all of the companies in the group and by two partners. Furthermore, there was a collateral in the form of business properties owned by those two partners.
The guarantors repaid the loan for the principal debtor and the creditor's rights passed to them. This included he pledgee's rights. However, one of the partners who issued one of the guarantees elected to foreclose on the property pledged as a collateral. The task of the lawyers was: to save the pledged property.
The lawyers succeeded in proving that at the time of filing the lawsuit the terms of the pledge agreements had expired in a manner similar to the rules applying to guarantee agreements.
Such conditions are prescribed by law. If the term of the guarantee is not specified in the relevant agreement, it terminates provided that the creditor does not file a claim against the guarantor within one year after the date of maturity of the secured obligation. When the maturity of the obligation is not specified and cannot be determined, the guarantee shall terminate.
In our case, the agreements had expired. There was no longer any opportunity to foreclose on the properties. The court decided to dismiss the claims in full.