Recovery of damages after a fire: defending against a claim

In 2015, a fire broke out at a shopping mall in one of the cities of Kuzbass. The flame first developed in the premises of a major federal retail chain store. The fire destroyed or damaged not only the premises of that store but also other areas and structural elements of the shopping mall.

In 2018, two claims were filed with the Kemerovo Region Commercial Court by the management company and the owners of the shopping mall for the recovery of more than RUB 66 mln of damages in the aggregate.

The claimants demanded compensation for the costs incurred to renovate damaged structural elements of the building, inseparable improvements existing in its premises (repair and decoration elements) and lost profits in the form of unpaid rent that otherwise would have been paid under individual leases. What should the tenants of the areas affected by the fire do? Can they get the claims filed by the owners of the shopping mall dismissed?

Case was handled by

A fire broke out at a shopping mall. The flame first developed in the premises of a federal retail chain store. The fire destroyed or damaged not only the premises of that store but also other areas and elements of the shopping mall. Two claims were filed with a Commercial Court by the management company and the owners of the shopping mall for the recovery of more than RUB 66 mln of damages.

The claimants demanded compensation for the costs incurred to renovate damaged structural elements of the building, inseparable improvements existing in its premises (repair and decoration elements) and lost profits in the form of unpaid rent that otherwise would have been paid under individual leases.

The task of the lawyers was: to protect the company of the federal level from losses. The complexity of the case: by the time the claims were filed, the areas had already been partially renovated.

The lawyers did the following:

1. Identified:

- the person responsible for the fire in the store premises; - the causes for fire alarm failure; - signs in the measures made by the management company and owners of the shopping mall indicative of their attempts to increase the amount of damage caused by the fire, and, accordingly, monetary compensation; - a list of all damages in the shopping mall caused by the fire; - cost of the work done to remedy the damage caused.

2. Initiated necessary forensic examinations, interrogated the experts and defended their opinions.

It took the courts about three years and more than 80 court sessions, 6 forensic examinations and multiple requests for documents and information to address all issues.

The efforts resulted in the claims being reduced to RUB 8.8 mln in the first proceedings and to RUB 39.2 mln in the second proceedings.

Related materials

We are here to help, please fill out the form below: